MONDAY DISCUSSION: RECENT SPOTS FOR PRIMO VIA SAATCHI & SAATCHI - WHAT DO WE THINK?
Client: Fonterra
Product: Primo
Agency: Saatchi & Saatchi New Zealand
ECD: Mike O'Sullivan
CD: Toby Talbot
Creatives: Andy DiLallo, Jay Benjamin and Cameron Harris
Agency Producer: Fiona Champtaloup
Production Company: Robber's Dog
Director: Adam Stephens
Producer: Mark Foster
posted by CB at 11/13/2006 06:57:00 am
25 Comments:
Awesome work, best from Saatchi in ages.
9:51 am NZDT
Well before the bitching starts, my honest opinion is that there is nothing wrong with these. Infact it even made me giggle. They are so silly they reach giggle status. Don't know if they're great. But good to see someone managing to get half decent ad out. I take my hat off to ya.
10:01 am NZDT
That's great. I love 'oddvertising' when it's done well and I've never seen a NZ ad that's done it successfully. Congrats.
11:04 am NZDT
To be honest they seem to miss a trick for me. Beautifully done. Not that funny.
12:06 pm NZDT
I like the second one - reminds me of the TUI ad. First one, not so much.
12:25 pm NZDT
Not funny. But i don't think they were spose to be. Right?
Remind's me a bit of MTV ads.
Not sure really what to say about them.
1:17 pm NZDT
Who cares? Lost the business now, should have done some good work when it was hard to get through.
4:01 pm NZDT
Hmmm, must have been a fun shoot with all that bouncing. Think they try a bit hard to be 'out there' and down with 'the kids'. Don't like the line much either.
5:40 pm NZDT
Maddocks/FreshUp 1
O'Sullivan/Primo 0
7:28 pm NZDT
I'll go ahead and say it...
Genius.
It amuses me to see people seeming to hate just for the sake of it. When was the last time you did something worthy of everyones jealousy?
9:47 pm NZDT
Okay, I'm a little drunk, but I just saw an ad with two toothbrushes talking to eachother. After that, I saw an ad where metal puzzle pieces were falling from the sky with the end thought 'you're the missing piece'.
These are pretty fucking good.
10:54 pm NZDT
AXIS GOLD -
5:52 pm NZDT
Fuck me.
Are you seriously that desperate to work out the idea?
Here it is in simple terms for you:
Tits and violence.
Entertaining and I'm sure boys will be drinking Primo in their sleep.
Speaking for men everywhere, stop listening to Wham and pull your head in. You're letting your side down.
That's assuming you're a bloke of course. If not, let me know and I'll whip something else up in reply.
1:18 am NZDT
9:17 you are embarrassing yourself.
7:57 am NZDT
It's a nice campaign in my opinion.
It's also a massive step up from the original Primo campaign out of Scratchies Welly that had a CGI man and dog in a car.
I think all the ad students writing drivel should really go back to their mailers and have a nice cool glass of 'back the fuck off'.
2:33 pm NZDT
9:17 It's simple
Undies = ice cream
Tits and Ass = milk
what's so hard to work out here?
11:46 am NZDT
I think 1.18 answered 9.17 question.
Tits and violence is not an idea. Not in my eyes anyway.
But since you all think its so great thats cool.
12:37 pm NZDT
My 2c worth: interesting that the fundamental problem of ads like these never seems to get a comment - i.e. that you alientate 50% of a potential market by assuming everyone is sucked in by robotic models in bikinis.
Seriously witty advertising attracts more than a 30 second rise in hormones, it generates a real interest and affection for a brand.
As a female this ad (the second one mainly) is plain out cliched and boring, and lowers my opinion of Primo itself. A job well done!
7:15 pm NZDT
Totally agree with girly art director.
4:21 pm NZDT
Unless of course you saw the research which says Primo has a massive male skew and that Wave (competitor brand) is almost solely drunk by males. Spotty teenage males seem to like their flavoured milk - and so tits and ass is a perfect fit I would've thought. I agree with girly art director in general but when the brand is so obviously meant to be in that area - it'd be very shortsighted not to go there. Thoughts?
12:00 pm NZDT
Thoughts, 12.00 PM? Right...Then aren't Primo preaching to the converted? If spotty teenage males like flavoured milk - whether it's Primo or Wave - why not grow the market across to females? We get thirsty too & from a healthy-bones perspective, need the stuff more than spotty boys anyway. Zig while the others are zagging, I say... which reminds me - whatever happened to Zap - probably the first flavoured milk ever in a carton? And Mooove?
5:37 pm NZDT
Not to point out the obvious here but there are TWO ads. One obviously whole heartedly attracts young lads...and of course lesbians. The other is a little more universal. So there you go, bases covered.
I think the ads also alienate Chinese people.
7:28 pm NZDT
Hmmm - although I agree on your zig when others zag I disagree with your rationale here. Using the same sort of thoughts we could say that Jags should really be targeted towards the low socio-economic families with 3 or more kids because they've already dominated the rich-fucker market. Likewise, Levis should really target the elderly because they already have a great presence with the youth and middle aged market. In short, I think it is extremely naive to talk to a group of people that is completely mutually exclusive to the flavoured milk drinking market. True, female teenagers drink flavoured milk but so infrequently it really doesn't warrant a blip on the sales markets. The reason: because flavoured milk isn't a coming of age or an early twenties drink that females care to associate themselves with. When was the last time you saw at Uni a girl pull a bottle of wave out of her bag in a lecture and drink it? It has and will always be a pump bottle or some deriative. Milk just isn't sexy to a female and when you're in the 15-25 year age group they're just not going to be tempted by it. hence a waste of advertising effort and time. Why zig when a secondary market doesn't care to come with you on your journey. God you're beautiful, I can smell your perfume in the evening air.
10:07 pm NZDT
10.07PM, what a deliciously eloquent answer. Point taken. And how perceptive of you also...I am wearing the 'Beautiful' perfume by Ralph Lauren.
9:46 am NZDT
Thanks. I guess that really sums it up. Ralph Lauren and Moooo (chocolate) don't really go together. Do they? Nice chatting about it though with someone as open as yourself. I'm sure in another life we'll come back as maple-oaks, side by side, and talk more about this subject (circa 4327 AD).
8:49 pm NZDT
Post a Comment
<< Home