“We wanted it to look like the kind of commercial that could have been made in the 70s, all created in camera and with an authentic feel,” Savage said. “The whole creative team was of the same strong view in this regard.”
What a negative bunch of comments. Not exactly constructive criticism either. Why is it that the creatives conceive the idea but it's the director that gets the all the shit?
I see this TIC TAC spot written about in international mags. Think; good for them, but don't bother to look at the spot.
Then I read a great critique for this ad on Ad News. Then find out it has been done from my home, NZ. So I track this spot down on this blog.
All i can say is it's very embarrassing. Not the spot, which by the way I loved. I'm talking about the bitter comments.
The PES comments are fair enough and opens a big and old argument about adverts. but the rest seem bitchy and dumb. And such mindlessness follows EVERY decent ad posted here.
It undermines this blog, but more importantly it undermines the NZ ad industry.
I worked in NZ and now working in London. I hope no one else from overseas reads these bad comments. They make us look silly and childish.
Let’s get behind good work produced here and not be a bitchy small town.
16 Comments:
Nice animation. No idea.
12:06 pm NZST
research,
http://www.eatpes.com/fireworks.html
2:03 pm NZST
Bursting with more what?
2:58 pm NZST
Maybe they could show the press release before the first airing so everyone will understand why it's so good.
Horrible ad.
5:16 pm NZST
“We wanted it to look like the kind of commercial that could have been made in the 70s, all created in camera and with an authentic feel,” Savage said. “The whole creative team was of the same strong view in this regard.”
You certainly achieved that!
8:06 pm NZST
pes?
12:24 am NZST
I like it. Well done.
8:06 am NZST
"The campaign is airing in Western Australia as a test market."
Let's hope they leave it there.
8:34 am NZST
What a negative bunch of comments. Not exactly constructive criticism either. Why is it that the creatives conceive the idea but it's the director that gets the all the shit?
9:33 am NZST
9.33
Is it really that the director is getting all the shit? A little defensive don't you think. Question is, who posted it proudly on the blog?
Also, did the creatives conceive it or did they rip it?
10:29 am NZST
Whoever is to blame, director or creatives, doesn't alter the fact that it isn't very good. No idea, poorly executed.
11:20 am NZST
It's not shit - just very average. All technique and no idea.
11:34 am NZST
Check out the PES clip. It's a rip, the whole rip, and nothing but the rip.
3:08 pm NZST
The ads crap, end of discussion.
10:38 pm NZST
And it had 2 producers !! So it must have been well produced, right ?
11:40 pm NZST
Right then.
I see this TIC TAC spot written about in international mags. Think; good for them, but don't bother to look at the spot.
Then I read a great critique for this ad on Ad News. Then find out it has been done from my home, NZ. So I track this spot down on this blog.
All i can say is it's very embarrassing. Not the spot, which by the way I loved. I'm talking about the bitter comments.
The PES comments are fair enough and opens a big and old argument about adverts. but the rest seem bitchy and dumb. And such mindlessness follows EVERY decent ad posted here.
It undermines this blog, but more importantly it undermines the NZ ad industry.
I worked in NZ and now working in London. I hope no one else from overseas reads these bad comments. They make us look silly and childish.
Let’s get behind good work produced here and not be a bitchy small town.
GOOD WORK FROM NZ BENEFITS NZ.
With love
Keith L
x
11:23 pm NZST
Post a Comment
<< Home